Showing posts with label Recall of witness. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recall of witness. Show all posts

18 June 2022

Calling for the concerned volume of a registered deed and giving explanations (O/C suit No. 124/2012)

The concerned Officer-in-Charge, the record room of Sadar Sub-Registrar, Rajshahi is summoned for producing the concerned volume of a registered deed and giving explanations.    

        Seen. Perused the materials on record. Upon such perusal, it appears that the Sadar Sub-Registrar was ordered a second time dated 30/01/2022 AD to produce the concerned volume of the Deed No. 20692 of 1972 before the court on 13.02.2022. Accordingly, the Sadar Sub-Registrar and officer-in-charge of the Sadar Record Room informed this court through a letter dated 09.02.2022. In this letter, it is mentioned that-

                            “রাজশাহীর সদর সাব-রেজিষ্ট্রী অফিসে রেজিস্ট্রীকৃত গত ইং ২৩/১২/১৯৭২ তারিখের দলিল নং ২০৬৯২, বালাম নং- ৭০, পাতা ৯২ হইতে ৯৪ নং পৃষ্ঠায় লিপিবদ্ধ বালামবহি খানা.... দীর্ঘ দিন যাবৎ অনুসন্ধান করিয়া যথাস্থানে খুঁজিয়া না পাওয়ায়...এবং বিগত ২০০৪ সালে পুরাতন রেকর্ডরুম হইতে নতুন রেকর্ডরুমে স্থানান্তরের সময় যে তালিকা করা হয়েছিল সে তালিকাতে ১৯৭২ সালের ৭০নং বালাম বহির উল্লেখ নাই।”

Upon perusal of the materials available on record, the court found that the litigant parties have submitted two Jabeda Nakol (duplicates) of the deed No. 20692/72 before the court; and such copies of the deed in question are provided in 2012 and 2018 from the office of the Sadar Record Room (Rajshahi) and now, those are kept on record. It is pertinent to mention that these two certified copies of the Deed No. 20692/72 contain two different volume numbers, namely 70 and 180.  As a result, the court finds inconsistency and contradictory information displayed on the certified copies of the deed.

Hence, it is ordered that the officer-in-charge, Sadar Record Room (Rajshahi) be present in person before the court on the next fixed date to explain to his given information as required. The next date is fixed on 23.02.2022 for F.P.H. Inform the concerned of this order.

continue reading Calling for the concerned volume of a registered deed and giving explanations (O/C suit No. 124/2012)

07 June 2022

Order allowing the recall petition in the family suit No. 66/2020

Seen. Heard. Today was fixed for another fresh effort regarding post-trial reconciliation. However, the plaintiff side also placed a petition for the recall of the PW-01 and the examination of two new witnesses on her behalf. Heard both parties. As such, it becomes decisive that such an attempt has not been successful so far. The record is taken up for passing the necessary order. In the present context, this is a family suit, where at the trial, the recording of evidence at the instances of both parties has already been concluded. The defendant side strongly objected to this petition because the plaintiffs should not be permitted to travel beyond the legal boundaries set out in section 6 of the 1985 Family Court Ordinance and not be allowed to fill lacunas discovered during trials.

On the careful perusal of the materials on record, it also transpires that the court finds no legal hindrance to recall the PW-01 in letting her submit the mentioned documents on her support. The defendant's side will have legal leverage to make a cross-examination of her. The general legal parlance is that the court may at any stage of a suit recall any witness who has already been examined for cogent reasons, and the exercise of such power is permissible only in exceptional situations. Besides, the court understands that the power of recall is very wide but could not be exercised mechanically. Even, the court may give leave to a party to recall a witness to give evidence about a matter raised by the evidence adduced by another party, being a matter on which the witness was not cross-examined, if the evidence concerned are materials to decide the real controversy and mooting matters disclosed in a suit.

Now consider the prayer for new two witnesses to be examined afresh after the end of the trial. The first one is Mr. Hajrat Ali, who issued an heir certificate on the demise of the defendant Mokbul Hosen, the original defendant. This certificate is marked exhibited as a documentary piece of evidence with objection. The other one is one Shomser Ali, who is a clerk of an Ld. Advocate. On perusal of the depositions given by the PW 01-02 as well as the plaint, it appears that there is no single mention of the name or context regarding Mr. Shomser Ali. The bottom line is that the moot point of this suit is the validity of the marriage. So, the facts encompassing the solemnization of marriage determine the competency of any witness in this suit. 

Accordingly, section 6(3) of the said Ordinance pertinently spells out that the plaint shall contain all material facts relating to the dispute and shall contain a schedule giving the names and addresses of the witnesses intended to be produced in support of the plaint, and in default, the plaintiff may, with the permission of the Court, call any witness at any later stage, if the Court considers such evidence expedient in the interest of justice. As such, it is the court’s view that the proposed witness Mr. Hajrat Ali issuing the said heir certificate could be allowed to be examined before the court, but Mr. Shomser Ali does not stand on the same footing.

Hence, it is ordered that the petition dated 07/04/2022 is allowed in part. Mr. Hajrat Ali as mentioned in the petition is hereby permitted to be examined and called for on the plaintiff’s behalf. In addition, the PW-01 is also permitted to be recalled for the purposes disclosed in the very petition only. 
continue reading Order allowing the recall petition in the family suit No. 66/2020