Showing posts with label Partition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Partition. Show all posts

30 May 2022

Order passed on the injunction petition in the other class suit No. 322/21

Seen. Perused the petition under Order 39 Rule 1/2 of the 1908 Code of Civil procedure, and the supporting affidavit, written objection thereto, submitted documents, and the record. On such perusal, it appears to the court that this is a suit for Partition. The plaintiff also placed a petition invoking an injunction order against the defendant's side.

Heard. The record is taken up for passing the necessary order.

The substance of the Petition:

             The plaintiff’s case, in a nutshell, reveals that the plaintiffs had been in possession of the suit land since inheriting the same from their predecessors. Meanwhile, an oral partition was taken place allocating o.25 acres of land in the RS plot No. 1639. The plaintiffs also claim that they are now in exclusive possession of the lands, comprising in that plot measuring 0.1250 acres of lands scheduled to the petition, at the southern part by way of cultivating mango trees.

However, the defendant No. 01, 16-17 are forcibly trying to dispossess them from the land specified in the schedule to the suit. The allegation goes as such that upon resistance by the plaintiff side, the defendants intimidated the plaintiffs and kept continuing the same. The very injunction petition is hereby placed before the court for restraining the defendants from their continuing encroachment.

Objections of the Opposite Party:

Defendant No. 01, 16-17 submitted written objections thereto, the brief of which encapsulates that the averment of the plaintiffs on the fact of the aforesaid forceful dispossession from the land specified in the schedule to the suit is totally phony and falsified. The fact of the resistance by the plaintiff side caused towards the defendants, who intimidated the plaintiffs and kept continuing the construction on the land in question, is fabricated and has been brought into being for causing damages to the defendant. Instead, the defendants stated above replies that they purchased 0.1250 acres of lands on the western side of the plot, comprising in the RS plot No. 1639, from the subsequent heirs of recorded tenant one Shabur Sardar via registered deed No. 4184/20. Since then, they have been in exclusive possession of that suit land in question by building pakka boundary. Thus, the defendants asserted that they have been in exclusive possession of the suit land in question as such. Hence, due to lacking of prima facie case and possession, inter alia, the petition is liable to be dismissed.

Point for determination:

Whether the plaintiff may get the relief prayed for?

Discussions and Decisions: 

            No doubt, the so-called trinity of principles on which rests the foundation of any order of injunction is the cornerstone of a party’s pleadings. On careful perusal of the pleadings’ averment and the respective petition along with submitted documents (RS khatian No. 38, deed Nos. 0665/80, 3271/99, 1861/92; and some others, it conspicuously appears to the court that the plaintiff shows some material facts which obviously carry him to the trial with his suit. Since a finding on 'prima facie case' would be a finding of fact, it appears that a substantial question has already been raised bona fide, which needs investigation and a decision on merits. Therefore, since the plaintiff side demonstrates a ‘good and arguable case’ in his favor by raising a fair question for determination; it is needless to put that a prima facie case is vividly established (not to be confused with prima facie title).  However, the defendants’ robust assertion of facts fairly outlines some focal issues, but they in fact legally stand beyond the instant context’s domain.

02. As this is a suit for partition, it would be trite to say that as per the record, both sides are in joint possession of the whole land scheduled to the plaint. Here, the plaintiff states in his respective petition that they had in possession of the suit land, specifically 0.1250 acres of lands on the southern side of the plot, comprised in the RS plot No. 1639. In support of the plaintiff’s averments as such, a photograph is placed before the court for its cognizance. On the other hand, the O.P. submitted his purchased deed No. 4184/20 and claims his exclusive possession in the suit land as aforesaid. To note here, both parties to the suit were also present in the courtroom and the court asked them for explanations of the submitted image. Being asked for as such, both sides claim that they are in possession of the suit plot No. 1630 on different corners, one on the southern and the other on the western. So, both parties are presumed to be in possession of that plot but on different sides.

03. Moreover, the materials on record are unable to decisively explain the real situation of their specific possession. A copy of a lease deed regarding the suit plot is submitted herewith, but that deed was effective not beyond the end of the year 2014 so far. Even, it appears that 0.25 acres of lands of the RS plot No. 3639 were leased out, which has already lost its’ significance on the current purposes. Furthermore, the locally made allotment speaks out the same. So, there is a dubious condition regarding the issue at hand. Although the petitioner is trying to claim that a report from the land office proceeding supports their current possession and title, they place no proof that disregards the presumptive value of the defendants’ mutation khatian. So, it is contextually opined that whether the plaintiff is in exclusive possession in the specified portion of the suit land cannot be decided upon the materials available on the record right now without taking further pieces of evidence. Accordingly, it appears that although the plaintiff side cogently appears to have currently been in possession of the plot in question, it would, without taking further evidence at trial, not be conducive to deciding the petitioners’ exclusive possession of the particular location of the suit plot.

04. The next points are whether the plaintiffs are going to suffer irreparable loss and whether the balance of convenience and inconvenience favors them. Of irreparable injury', such injury cannot be adequately remedied by damages. The remedy by damages would be inadequate if the compensation ultimately payable to the plaintiff in case of success in the suit would not place him in the position in which he was before the injunction was refused. In fact, dispossession from the land always tends to irreparable loss, which cannot be adequately remedied by damages. Moreover, a ‘comparative hardship or mischief’ that is likely to be caused to a party if the injunction is refused, will be greater than that it is likely to be caused to the other party if the injunction is granted. So, in applying this principle, the Court has to weigh the amount of substantial and probable injury to either party, the court ought to look at from the point of view of whether on the refusal of the injunction the plaintiff would suffer irreparable loss and injury keeping in view the strength of the parties’ case.

05. Since this is a partition suit and there are no sufficient materials on record to decide the parties’ exclusive possession of that particular plot. So, there is a real controversy regarding the specific possession, which would be decided only at trial after conducting a local investigation in this partition suit. So, considering the lack of precision, certainty, and perspicuity of such nature in the alleged ijmali possession, it is much safe to hold that speaking out about the irreparable injury alleged to have occurred to the plaintiff if no injunction were granted and decide the question of the balance of convenience and inconvenience to the parties fall short in any details to be determined due to the findings made hereinbefore. Hence, whether compensation can be an adequate remedy to the plaintiffs, or irreparable injury would be the outcome of the refusing the petition is consequently ruled out.

04. Apart from a prima facie case and a balance of convenience, the petitioner must establish also a case of ‘irreparable injury’ to occur to him if no injunction were granted. It is further well-conversant that the phrases `prima facie case’, `balance of convenience’, and ` irreparable loss’ are not rhetoric phrases for incantation, but words of width and elasticity to meet myriad situations presented by man’s ingenuity in given facts and circumstances; so always is to be hedged with sound exercise of judicial discretion to meet the interest of justice. Therefore, the court is of opinion that interference by the Court would rather result in irreparable injury to any party to the suit, and thus, it appears to be expedient not to intervene as such. Keeping all of these things in the appreciation of the appearing facts and aspects, the court is of the view that the plaintiff’s prayer for a temporary injunction is not worth-being allowed.

Hence, it is ordered

That the application for temporary injunction dated 29.09.21 be disallowed on contest.

The next date is 27.06.2022 AD for W.S. 

continue reading Order passed on the injunction petition in the other class suit No. 322/21

27 February 2022

Ex parte order passed in the other class suit No. 339/2021 (partition)

The record is taken up for passing necessary order. This is a suit for partition of the suit property. Perused the plaint, deposition of the plaintiff as P.W- 01, the documentary pieces of evidence marked as exhibit No. 01, and the case record.

02. Upon such perusal and consideration of the adduced evidences, it appears that the property comprised in SA khatian No. 395 belonged to one Rahim Sarkar @ Rahimuddin, transferred the suit land to the plaintiff and the defendant No. 01-02 via a registered deed of No. 16867/1964, and thus, they have been in ejmali possession of 15 decimal land since then [vide SA khatian, Deed No. 16867/1964]. The plaintiff also admitted that out of the land described in the respective plot scheduled to the plaint, they are now in ejmali possession of only 15 decimal lands; and the rest land of 03 decimal is in the possession of local government bodies. Nothing is proved to the contrary [Pw-01].

03. On perusal of the plaintiff’s gift deed, it appears that there are three persons named as donee, who are the plaintiff and the two defendants of the very suit. But, a close reading of the deed on board, it further transpires that no share of those donees is mentioned in the averment of the deed in question. So, the question arises of how and what share of land will vest to those donees, the parties to the suit. In evidence, it is noticeable that the plaintiff claims an equal share of the property described in the deed. The deed itself exposes in a way that no consideration money comes from the donees as the deed is a gift one. So, the concept of joint or co-ownership comes into play here.  

04. Section 45 of the 1872 Transfer of Property Act deals with joint transfer for consideration. Since the deed in question is a gift deed and there is no consideration paid by each of donees, another question also comes into play whether the provision of section 45 of the 1872 Transfer of Property Act would be applicable to our case at hand. An undertaking of a textual and structural analysis reflects that section 45 of the Transfer of Property Act is unique in ways that it runs contrary to Section 91 of the Evidence Act, 1872; meaning that section 91 lends sanctity to the vesting of property through property deeds, whereas section 45 chips away at this sanctity. Section 45 of the Transfer of Property Act does not divest title. It only helps understand the extent to which the title had been vested to begin with. And the second paragraph of Section 45 itself suggests that a presumption is cast by the statute in favor of equal ownership.

05. Accordingly, it is cogent to opine that since there is no consideration paid by any of the donees to the deed in question, the presumption of equal ownership could help the court decide their share of the suit property. There is also a legal understanding that title may never be perfected unless one of the co-owners seeks a partition by metes and bounds, or seeks declaratory relief. Therefore, for all practical purposes therefore, because section 45 may actually work to divest co-owners of their title, in a suit for partition by metes and bounds, the partition can be made on the basis of admission of the parties. In our occasion, since this is a declaration of title and partition, the court has jurisdiction to decide these issues in the light of the materials on the record.

06. In evidence, the PW-01 asserted that all the parties to the suit are now in ejmali possession of only 15 decimal lands described in the scheduled to the plaint. The plaintiff thus claims only 05 decimal of land out of those 15 decimal lands on the basis of her co- ownership. The PW-01 also claims that she has been in possession of 5 decimal of land and has a betel-leaf-field on her 5 decimal lands, and defendant No.01 has his house on his 5 decimal shares of lands. However, the RS khatian No. 334 is prepared in the name of defendant No. 01 only. Since Khatian is not evidence of title, and the plaintiff has proved his possession in his suit land with credible evidence, it can legally be opined that the plaintiff has successfully established his title and possession to the suit land he claims as such. Pertinently, this is a suit that is being tried ex parte; and there is no material on record that goes contrary to the plaintiff’s claims.

07. Generally, the law is settled that the burden lies on the Plaintiff to prove his case and he must succeed on his own strength only and not at the weakness of the adversary. Furthermore, in this respect, it is also pertinent to mention that ‘the plaintiffs in order to succeed must establish their own case by credible evidence and weakness of the defendants is no ground for awarding a decree in favor of the plaintiffs. The court holds that since the plaintiff’s case has been proved by evidence as well as sufficient implications on the points that she has a property deed that substantiates her ownership of 05 decimal of the scheduled land and also that she is in ejmali possession of the suit property. And thus, the plaintiff may also get relief under section 42 of the Specific Relief Act, 1877. Thus, the suit deserves to be decreed. As such, it is decided that the plaintiff may get the relief as prayed for.

In considering the aforesaid facts, documentary evidence, relevant laws, corroborative evidence, and encompassing conditions, it appears to the court that Plaintiff has successfully proved her right, title to & interest in 5 decimal land out of the suit landed property. And thus, the plaintiff has established his right, title, and interest in 05 decimal lands out of the suit landed property. It is also proved that the suit is filed within the period of limitation as well as the parties to the suit have a community of interest in the suit property. Although a suit for partition determines the share of the co-sharers inter se, only the plaintiff has prayed for a separate Saham in the present suit. For that reason, it can easily be concluded that no decision as to the Saham of residual suit property shall legally be given in the instant suit. As such, Plaintiff may get relief as prayed for. On consideration and cognizance of the Pleadings, facts, surrounding circumstances of the case, shreds of evidence on record, and relevant laws, the Court is of view that the suit deserves to be decreed ex parte.

Court fee paid is sufficient.

Hence, it is ordered that the suit be decreed in preliminary ex parte against the defendants without any order as to costs, allocating the plaintiff a separate Saham for 05 decimal of lands on partition out of the suit landed property described in the schedule to the Plaint. The parties are directed to amicably effect partition of the suit properties among themselves by metes and bounds within 30 (sixty) days from the date, failing which, the plaintiff shall be at liberty to have the partition through the court in accordance with law for making the preliminary decree final by appointing a civil court commissioner.

(Composed and corrected by)
 
 

continue reading Ex parte order passed in the other class suit No. 339/2021 (partition)

08 September 2021

Ex parte decree in a partition suit

 The record is taken up for passing necessary order. This is a suit for declaration of title and partition of the suit property. Perused the plaint, deposition of the plaintiff as P.W- 01, the documentary evidences marked as exhibits No. 01-02, and the case record.

Upon such perusal and consideration of the adduced evidences, it appears that the plaintiffs claim that the property comprised in CS khatian No. 13 belonged to one Ujal Mondol, Sujal Mondol and Meru Mondol. Likewise, SA khatian No. 18 was also published against the names of Ujal Mondol, Sujal Mondol and Meru Mondol. Sujal Mondol died leaving behind his two daughters and two brothers. Meru Mondol died leaving behind only brother Ujal Mondol. This way, Ujal Mondol became entitled to the land of 5.34 acre. Later on, Ujal Mondol died leaving behind only son Ramjan Ali, who becomes an owner of 5.34 acre of land, as his father belonged to. It was also claimed that the RS khatian No. 28 was prepared his name, along with some other stranger persons who do not have any entitlement to the suit land. Rather, the RS record should have been published against only the name of Ramjan ali.

The plaintiff as PW-01 also claimed that Ramjan Ali then died leaving behind three daughters who are the plaintiff Nos. 01-02 and the defendant No. 03. Accordingly, the plaintiffs Nos. 01-02 claim the separate share of 3.56 acre of land out the suit property since joint property is yet to be partitioned among the parties to the suit. In addition, the plaintiffs also claimed their share to the suit land to be declared for its’ erroneous entry of the names of persons except Ramjan Ali in the RS record of rights. Considering the documents adduced and other evidence presented before the court, it appears that the plaintiffs have proved their share of 3.56 acre of land inherited from their father Ramjan Ali.  Nothing is proved to the contrary.

Generally, law is settled that ‘the burden lies on the Plaintiff to prove his case and he must succeed on his own strength only and not at the weakness of the adversary’ (3 BLC 6). Furthermore, In this respect, it is also pertinent to mention that ‘the plaintiffs in order to succeed must establish their own case by credible evidence and weakness of the defendants is no ground for awarding a decree in favor of the plaintiffs. Since the plaintiff’s case has been proved by evidence as well as sufficient implications as stated above, the plaintiffs may also get relief under section of 42 of the Specific Relief Act, 1877. Thus, the suit deserves to be decreed. As such, it is decided that the plaintiff may get the relief as prayed for.

In considering the aforesaid facts, the Khatains, relevant laws, corroborative evidence and encompassing conditions, it appears to the court that the Plaintiffs have successfully proved their right, title to & interest in 3.56 acre land out of the suit landed property. It is also proved that the suit is filed within the period of limitation as well as the parties to the suit have community of interest in the suit property. Although a suit for partition determines the share of the co-sharers inter se, only plaintiff prayed for separate Saham in the present suit. For that reason, it can easily be concluded that no decision as to the Saham of residual suit property shall legally be given in the instant suit. As such, the Plaintiffs may get relief as prayed for. On consideration and cognizance of the Pleadings, facts, surrounding circumstances of the case, evidences on record and relevant laws, the Court is of view that the suit deserves to be decreed on contest.

Court fee paid is sufficient.

Hence,

it is  ordered that

the suit be decreed in preliminary on the contest against the defendants without any order as to costs, allocating the plaintiff a separate Saham for 3.56acre of land on partition out of the suit landed property described in the schedule to the Plaint. The parties are directed to amicably effect partition of the suit properties among themselves by metes and bounds within 60 (sixty) days from the date, failing which, the plaintiffs shall be at liberty to have the partition through the court in accordance with law for making the preliminary decree final by appointing a civil court commissioner.

(Composed and corrected by)

continue reading Ex parte decree in a partition suit