Showing posts with label Family Suit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Family Suit. Show all posts

26 June 2022

Judgement passed in the Family Suit No. 60/19 (dower money and maintenance)

HEADING OF JUDGEMENT IN ORIGINAL SUIT/CASE

District: Rajshahi                        

In the Court of Family Judge, Mohonpur, Rajshahi

Present: - Mr. Md. Abdul Malek, Judge, Family Court

Family Suit No. 60/19

Mst. Joli Begum, Plaintiff Versus Mr. Md. Hafijul Rahman, Defendant

The suit coming on trial ended and the argument was heard.

In the presence of...

And having stood for consideration to this day, the Court delivered the following judgment: This is a family suit instituted with a prayer for recovering unpaid dower money and maintenance against the Defendant.

 

The Plaintiffs’ Plaint in the nutshell:

A marriage was contracted and registered between the Plaintiff and the Defendant on 20/07/2019 upon fixing dower money at Tk. 3,00,000/. In the aftermath, the Defendant demanded dowry; and on refusal to give him dowry, he drove the Plaintiff away from his adobe on 01/08/2019 and then, she took shelter in her father’s house. From that time, the Plaintiff started staying at that abode and later on, she repudiated their marital tie on 04/08/2019. On 01/08/2019, the Plaintiff demanded unpaid dower money and her maintenance from the Defendant but the latter refused to pay the same; and hence the suit.

 

The Written Statement in Brief:

On the other hand, the Defendant contested the suit by filing written statement denying the material averments made in the plaint. He contended, inter alia, that the Plaintiff lacks in locus standi, the impugned facts are fabricated and fraudulent, and the very suit is legally untenable, unjustifiable; and dismissible for cloudy cause of actions.

The Defendant stated that the plaintiff is a spouse of his step brother, who got married to each other ten years ago and now, they have two offspring in their family. The defendant also claimed that there is or was no marriage between the plaintiff and the defendant; and they never reside under same roof upon marital knot. Since there was no marriage either through sharia law or registered nikahnama, there arises no question as to the dissolution by the plaintiff of that alleged marriage in between. Hence, the plaintiff is not entitled to get any reliefs as prayed for and the suit is liable to be dismissed.

 

Issues:

Considering the parties’ pleadings, the issues are framed with modifications for discussion in the following way:

1.     Whether the suit is maintainable in the present form and manner.

2.    Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get her dower money.

3.    Whether the plaintiff is entitled to iddat maintenance.

4.    Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get remedy as prayed for.

 

Discussions and Decisions

In proof of the claims, the Plaintiff examined herself as PW. 01, and other witnesses as PW 02-06, and produced documentary evidences marked as Exhibit No. 01-05. On the other side, the Defendant examined himself as DW 01 and another witness as DW-02. Another witness as CW-01 is also examined before the court. After the trial of the suit ended, the last reconciliation effort was failed and then, heard arguments from both sides.  

Issue No. 01:

The plaintiff filed the suit before this family court having jurisdiction under the provisions of the Family Court Ordinance, 1985; and paid proper court fees, with a prayer for a decree for dower and maintenance. Section 05 of the Family Court Ordinance, 1985 recognizes any aggrieved person’s right to file a lawsuit concerning the matter of dower and maintenance. So, since there appear no contrary materials to the aforesaid premise, it is decided that the suit is maintainable in the current form and manner. Hence, in the absence of materials to the contrary, the issue is settled in the plaintiff’s favor.

Issue No. 02 and 03:

On perusal of the materials available on record, it appears that it is admitted that marriage was contracted and registered between the plaintiff Joly Begum and her current husband, one Selim Reza (PW-05) and now the plaintiff is leading conjugal life with him (Selim Reza) with having two offspring in their family [vide PW-01, (cross-examination). Accordingly, it is conspicuous that there existed and now exists a spousal relationship between the plaintiff and Selim Reza to date. Consequently, as issue No. 02 suggests, there arises a pertinent question as to whether the plaintiff got legally married to the defendant meanwhile so that she should get dower money from the defendant.


04. In the search of an answer to the aforesaid question, it appears that the plaintiff claims in her pleading and evidence that her marriage with Selim Reza (allegedly 1st husband) was dissolved through a khua talaq on 20/04/19 (ext: 06) and then, following the event, she further married to the defendant Hafizul Rahman (allegedly 2nd husband) on 20/07/2019 upon fixing dower money at Tk. 3,00,000 [PW-01; ext: 01]. Having claimed as such, the plaintiff tried to establish a case on the point that she meanwhile got married to the defendant and thus, is entitled to dower money and maintenance. On the other hand, the defendant is found in total disagreement with the plaintiff in ways that the plaintiff is a spouse of his stepbrother, who got married to each other ten years ago and now, they are leading their marital life with having two offspring in their family. The defendant also claimed that there is or was no marriage between the plaintiff and the defendant, and they never reside under the same roof upon marital knot (vide DW-01). Likewise, the defendant claims that since there was no marriage either through sharia law or registered Nikahnama, there arises no question as to the dissolution by the plaintiff of that alleged marriage in between (DW. 01-02). Hence, the defendant claims on those premises that the plaintiff is not entitled to get any reliefs as prayed for.


05. Now, considering aforesaid propositions as such, another incidental question comes into play on the fact that whether the marital relationship between the plaintiff and Selim Reza meanwhile lawfully terminated or not. That is to say, was there any lawful marriage between them (plaintiff and defendant)? On perusal of the materials on record, it transpires in evidence that Selim Reza got examined as PW-05 who vividly deposed that the plaintiff is his spouse and spent 7/8 years together as a spouse, and now, they have two offspring in their family. He also asserted that he repudiated his marital tie with the plaintiff after the birth of their 2nd child through khula talaq in 2019. On the issue at hand, he unequivocally asserted that he did not serve notice of talaq to the concerned U.P. chairman. Even, the plaintiff did not place any evidence on the fact that the notice of khula talaq was served upon the concerned U.P. chairman.


06. However, on this very vital point, the plaintiff only put forward the certified copy of the registration of khula talaq (ext: 06), and thus, claims that the talaq in question becomes effective as such.  On the other hand, the defendant underscored his position on the demand that a spousal relationship between the plaintiff and Selim Reza exists to date since its inception. Accordingly, it becomes incumbent to consider the pertinent provisions of law that touch the ensuing facts. Section 7 of the 1961Muslim Family Laws Ordinance stipulates that “Any man who wishes to divorce his wife shall, as soon as may be after the pronouncement of talaq in any form whatsoever, give the Chairman notice in writing of his having done so, and shall supply a copy thereof to the wife. It also envisages that “Save, as provided in sub-section (5,), a talaq unless revoked earlier, expressly or otherwise, shall not be effective until the expiration of ninety days from the day on which notice under sub-section (1) is delivered to the Chairman.


07. The plain reading of the above statutory provision gives us a lucid understanding that any pronouncement of talaq shall not be effective until the expiration of ninety days from the day on which notice under sub-section (1) is delivered to the Chairman. The words “in any form whatsoever” appearing in section 7(1) of the Ordinance 1961 is very much significant; as it spells out that “in any form" means and includes khula talaq too; no matter whether talaq is registered or not), or no matter whether any modes of Talaq stated in Mahomedan Law. Because section 7 requires only a notice of a talaq to be given to the Chairman to give effect to divorce. In fact, Khula or Mubara'at is another form of talaq or dissolution of marriage by agreement Khula or Mubarat is stated in section 319 of Mulla's Principles of Mahomedan Law [19th Ed. 1990, (2010 reprint)].


08. Now, consider a bird's eye view on some judicial pronouncements on section 7 of The Ordinance of 1961. With regard to the objects, requirements, and consequences of section 7 of the 1961Ordinance, it has been highlighted that the object of section 7 of The Ordinance is to prevent the hasty dissolution of marriage by talaq proposed by the husband, unilaterally, without an attempt is being made to prevent disruption of matrimonial status [vide 15 DLR (SC) 9]. It has also been laid down that in the event of failure of compliance of provision of sub-section 1 of section 7 of The Ordinance a Talaq even if pronounced by a husband cannot be effective in law and the marriage between husband and wife subsists [vide Abdul Aziz vs Rezia Khatoon 21 DLR 733].


09. It has further been reported [46 DLR 700] that divorce under the Ordinance is not a unilateral act, and it precludes a divorce on talaq from being effective from a period of ninety days from the date of receipt of the notice by the Chairman and consequently marital status of the parties will not in any way change and parties in law will continue to remain, husband and wife, till the divorce is confirmed. Ninety days reconciliation period is to start from the date of receipt of notice by the Chairman, and not from the date when it was written. Although the failure of the Chairman to constitute an arbitration council or that of a duly constituted arbitration council to take necessary steps to bring about reconciliation is inconsequential, it is the legal position that there shall be not Talak in the eye of law unless provision contained in section 7(1) is sternly complied with; and marriage between husband and wife shall subsist. In the event of subsistence of the existing marriage, no man or woman can enter into a second marriage. And if he enters, he shall contribute himself to be punished under section 6(5) of the Ordinance. [vide Dilruba Aktar vs AHM Mohsin, 55 DLR 568].

 

10. Non-service of notice to the Chairman of the Union Parishad under the provision of this section cannot render ineffective divorce disclosed in an affidavit. [vide Sirajul Islam vs Helana Begum and others, 48 DLR 48]. The whole materials on record reveal that the Khula talaq in question was not disclosed in an affidavit. It was also aptly argued in an occasion reported in Md Sirajul Islam vs Mosammat Helena Begum, [1996 BLD 477] that “when divorce is clearly established by the conduct of the husband, mere non-service of notice upon the Chairman as enjoined by section 7 of the Ordinance does not render the divorce ineffective.” In this respect, it can be opined that with respect to the Khula talaq in question, a duty was cast upon the husband to give notice under section 7 of the said Ordinance. Here, the current husband of the plaintiff, Selim Reza, admitted in evidence (PW-05) that he did not discharge his duty to serve notice to the concerned U.P. chairman. Moreover, because Selim Reza is still leading his conjugal life with the plaintiff, his Khula talaq attempt was presumably not intended by him, not for eternity. Even, the non-service of notice to the chairman provided no change of reconciliation whatsoever.  Accordingly, it vividly transpires to the court that the conduct of the plaintiff and Selim Reza carries them nowhere in dissolving their marital tie.

 

11. Talaq pronounced by the wife must be communicated to the husband. In our case, it was the alleged khula talaq. A divorce by Khula is a divorce with consent. So, it is assumable that although the communication of consents was over and complete, the defendant was not that communicated husband; instead, her current husband was communicated as such (as admittedly, the defendant and the plaintiff’s current husband is not identical person). Hence, there arises no question as to effective communication between the plaintiff and defendant. In addition, the defendant does not admit the fact of any divorce between the plaintiff and her spouse Selim Reza. Accordingly, the conduct of the parties has no pertinence in deciding, whether the requirement of section 7(1) of the 1961 Ordinance was constructively compiled or not, or whether the intendment of the legislature is served. The literal or popular interpretation suggests that if the language of a statute is plain, the only duty of the court is to give effect to it, and the court has no business to look into the consequences of such interpretation.

 

12. Therefore, it becomes clear that “no notice” under section 7(1) means “no talaq”....unless the provisions of section 7(1) of the 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance are complied with regarding service of notice to the Chairman of Union Council. In essence, such a talaq attempt would fail to operate. Therefore, it is the court’s view that the alleged talaq between the plaintiff and her current spouse Selim Reza could not free her (plaintiff) to marry (the defendant) ‘meanwhile’. The provision of section 7(1) of the Ordinance was standing on their way [vide 15 DLR (SC) 9] To demystify, one may again come up with a question whether the deed of divorce (ext. 06), even if held to be genuine, would operate as a valid divorce under the current statutory provisions. The answer to this question, so as to the fact of the suit is pertinent, is resounding “no”; it would not operate as a valid divorce under the current statutory provisions of section 7(1) of the 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance. The boom line counsels that section 7(1) must sternly be complied with in order to give legal effect to an intended divorce. Hence, upon the aforesaid premise, it is the court’s view that in the subsistence of marital tie between the plaintiff and Selim Reza, the plaintiff’s claim that marriage was contracted and registered between the Plaintiff and the Defendant on 20/07/2019 upon fixing dower money at Tk. 3,00,000 is not sustainable in law.

 

13. Furthermore, as aforesaid, the defendant does not admit the marriage contract and denies the authenticity of the marriage registration (the plaintiff’s alleged second marriage). Although the certified copy of the Nikahnama is placed before that court, and later on divorce papers (ext: 1-5), a close perusal of the materials available on record, it speaks out that the fact of the plaintiff’s second marriage with the defendant appears to be incongruent and unconvincing. The PW-01 once stated in her cross-examination that her second marriage was done at the house of Altaf Kazi. She again stated at the office of Altaf Kazi. Altaf Kazi was not examined before the court; instead, Md. Shohrab Hosen as CW-01 deposed that Altaf was his assistant, and Altaf as a witness to the marriage and Altaf as Kazi are not the same person. Besides, PWs 01-02 stated that the marriage in question was contracted in the afternoon and in the presence of the plaintiff’s father, but PW-04 underscored that it was done at 8 PM (at night), and he omitted to mention the presence of her father at that occasion. In addition, the DW-01 denies his signatures on both Nikahnama and the acknowledgment of talaq notice. No expert evidence is led by either party too. However, the DW02 also asserted the fact of his ignorance of any marriage between the plaintiff and defendant, although he claims to be one of their close relatives.

 

Taking into consideration of the aforesaid facts, relevant laws, and ensuing circumstances, it is the court’s view that the whole fabric of the legal and evidentiary edifice cannot make the plaintiff stand on her own strength in proving her claims as such. So, the court is decisive on the point that the alleged talaq between the plaintiff and her husband Selim Reza was not effective, and thus, there was no valid marriage, allegedly contracted on 20/07/2019, between the Plaintiff and the Defendant upon fixing the aforesaid dower money. The relevant law is enunciated in section 256 of Mulla's Principles of Mahomedan Law [19th Ed. 1990, (2010 reprint)] that “no Mohamedan woman cannot have more than one husband at the same time.” Accordingly, the claims of the plaintiff are not sufficiently proved with convincing and unimpeachable evidence and thus, not sustainable in law. As a result, where there is no valid marriage, there is no question of dower or talaq between the plaintiff and defendant on board. Hence, the issues Nos. 02 and 03 are not decided in the plaintiff’s favor.

 

Issue No. 04:

In essence, since the issues Nos. 02 and 03 are not decided in the plaintiff’s favor, it is, therefore, held that the plaintiff is not entitled to get the relief as prayed for. Accordingly, in the light of the discussions and decisions and the consideration of pleadings, facts, surrounding circumstances, evidence both oral and documentary on record as well as relevant laws, the court is of view that the suit deserves to be dismissed on the contest.

 

The court fee paid is sufficient.

Hence, it is ordered that the suit be dismissed on contest against the Defendant without any order as to costs.

 

continue reading Judgement passed in the Family Suit No. 60/19 (dower money and maintenance)

17 June 2022

Ad-interim child maintenance is awarded during the pendency of the family Suit


 Seen. Heard. Perused the petitions of both sides and the material available on record. On such perusal and the consideration of the grounds enshrined in the defendant’s petition, it appears that an appeal is filed before the honorable Court of the District Judge (Rajshahi) against an order of this court passed in the instant suit but which order is challenged as such has not been reflected in the given information slip. Surprisingly, although today was fixed for F.P.H. at the instance of the defendant side, neither time is prayed, nor any witness is produced or any step is taken for making cross-examination of the PW-01, except furnishing the aforesaid information.

02. On the other hand, the plaintiff-side turned up with a petition seeking to fix the suit for an ex parte order since no lawful step is taken on the defendant side. In the hearing, the Ld. The advocate of the plaintiff-side pleaded that this suit was instituted on 01.04.19, and to date, only the PW-01 is examined so far. The suit is also concerned with child maintenance, a child now in the custody of the plaintiff. Moreover, it also transpires that the defendant’s petition for examining his thumb impression by the expert is kept on the record till the examination of the defendant before the court as a witness (vide order No. 23). Hearing as such and considering a fair opportunity for both parties, it is ordered that the defendant is ordered to be present before the court on the next fixed date for participating in the F.P.H as a last resort.

03. However, with regard to the plaintiff’s petition for an ad-interim order for child maintenance, it appears that the plaintiff's mother Mst. Golapi Aktar has also instituted the suit against the father defendant Mr. Md. Shofiqul Islam Liton for maintenance of their minor daughter Miss. Lamia Yasmin. Notably, the defendant unambiguously admits in his pleading that the minor child in question was born under his parental legitimacy; and the latter is now in her mother’s custody. Nothing appears to the contrary on such points. Today, the Ld. Advocate for the plaintiff side sought child maintenance from the father defendant on ad interim basis and no further adjournment of hearing the suit. It is also pleaded that the custodian mother plaintiff suffers from thalassemia and she has to take blood every 2/3 month each, and also she has hardship for having no source of income of her own. Conversely, the defendant works in an engendering shop.

04. Such conditions and observations made hereinbefore make the court recollect that Muslim personal law naturally requires a father to maintain his children and take them every care. Even much weight is attached to children's maintenance under Muslim law. A child even gets priority over parents as far as maintenance is concerned. It is underscored as such that the mother cannot be compelled to provide milk to a child, but the father is under a duty to provide a nurse. Likewise, the father is bound to maintain even if he is indigent or the children are in the mother's custody. Accordingly, the court satisfactorily holds that the defendant currently should pay interim maintenance to the child in question for her sustenance, food, garments, and overall wellbeing; otherwise, it would not prevent the purpose of the suit and the cause of justice from being frustrated.

Hence, the defendant is hereby ordered to pay interim maintenance at the rate of TK. 2000 per month to the impugned child under the provision of 16A of the 1985 Family Court Ordinance from the date at the start of each month till further order. In default, the custodian plaintiff may take steps in accordance with the law.

The next date is fixed 07.11.2021 for F.P.H. for the defendant-side. Inform Ld. Advocates of both parties of the order, and send a copy of this order to the defendant as well. 

continue reading Ad-interim child maintenance is awarded during the pendency of the family Suit

07 June 2022

Order allowing the recall petition in the family suit No. 66/2020

Seen. Heard. Today was fixed for another fresh effort regarding post-trial reconciliation. However, the plaintiff side also placed a petition for the recall of the PW-01 and the examination of two new witnesses on her behalf. Heard both parties. As such, it becomes decisive that such an attempt has not been successful so far. The record is taken up for passing the necessary order. In the present context, this is a family suit, where at the trial, the recording of evidence at the instances of both parties has already been concluded. The defendant side strongly objected to this petition because the plaintiffs should not be permitted to travel beyond the legal boundaries set out in section 6 of the 1985 Family Court Ordinance and not be allowed to fill lacunas discovered during trials.

On the careful perusal of the materials on record, it also transpires that the court finds no legal hindrance to recall the PW-01 in letting her submit the mentioned documents on her support. The defendant's side will have legal leverage to make a cross-examination of her. The general legal parlance is that the court may at any stage of a suit recall any witness who has already been examined for cogent reasons, and the exercise of such power is permissible only in exceptional situations. Besides, the court understands that the power of recall is very wide but could not be exercised mechanically. Even, the court may give leave to a party to recall a witness to give evidence about a matter raised by the evidence adduced by another party, being a matter on which the witness was not cross-examined, if the evidence concerned are materials to decide the real controversy and mooting matters disclosed in a suit.

Now consider the prayer for new two witnesses to be examined afresh after the end of the trial. The first one is Mr. Hajrat Ali, who issued an heir certificate on the demise of the defendant Mokbul Hosen, the original defendant. This certificate is marked exhibited as a documentary piece of evidence with objection. The other one is one Shomser Ali, who is a clerk of an Ld. Advocate. On perusal of the depositions given by the PW 01-02 as well as the plaint, it appears that there is no single mention of the name or context regarding Mr. Shomser Ali. The bottom line is that the moot point of this suit is the validity of the marriage. So, the facts encompassing the solemnization of marriage determine the competency of any witness in this suit. 

Accordingly, section 6(3) of the said Ordinance pertinently spells out that the plaint shall contain all material facts relating to the dispute and shall contain a schedule giving the names and addresses of the witnesses intended to be produced in support of the plaint, and in default, the plaintiff may, with the permission of the Court, call any witness at any later stage, if the Court considers such evidence expedient in the interest of justice. As such, it is the court’s view that the proposed witness Mr. Hajrat Ali issuing the said heir certificate could be allowed to be examined before the court, but Mr. Shomser Ali does not stand on the same footing.

Hence, it is ordered that the petition dated 07/04/2022 is allowed in part. Mr. Hajrat Ali as mentioned in the petition is hereby permitted to be examined and called for on the plaintiff’s behalf. In addition, the PW-01 is also permitted to be recalled for the purposes disclosed in the very petition only. 
continue reading Order allowing the recall petition in the family suit No. 66/2020

08 May 2022

Ex Parte order passed in the family suit No. 57/2020 (dower and maintenance)

     Seen. The record is taken up for passing necessary order. This is a family suit instituted seeking for recovering Dower money and Maintenance against the Defendant. Perused the Planit, Plaintiff’s deposition given as PW-01, documentary evidence marked as Exhibit No.1, and the record. It appears that a marriage was contracted and registered between Plaintiff and the Defendant on 23/04/2010. A son, Plaintiff No. 02, was born on 10/10/2011 in the womb of the plaintiff No.01 at the defendant’s paternal legitimacy. Exhibit No. 01, the certified copy of the Nikahnama, demonstrates that Dower was fixed Tk. 35,000/- only for their marriage with the instant payment of Tk. 100 in terms of ornaments. It is also found that Plaintiff admitted Talak through which their marital tie got dissolved and terminated. Hence, it is decided that the plaintiff No. 01 is entitled to get her unpaid dower money at Taka 34,900/.

    With assigning some reasons, Plaintiff also prayed for the recovery of maintenance for herself and her child, plaintiff No. 02. The child in question is admittedly their offspring. It is now well-settled that Muslim personal law naturally requires a father to maintain his children and take them every care. Even much weight is attached to children's maintenance under Muslim law. It is to be underscored by saying that the mother cannot be compelled to provide milk to a child but the father is under a duty to provide a nurse. He is bound to maintain even if he is indigent or the children are in the custody of the mother. But such maintenance is to be assessed in cognizance of the father’s affordable conditions or the customs and practices.

    Pertinently, the impugned minor is an 11-year old-female person who as of nearly 06 years old, who needs adequate food, education, and lodging as well as decent raiment. It is also asserted that the defendant is a riksha peddler, and also has some land to cultivate. He is claimed to be capable of working too. In consideration of the pleading, facts, surrounding circumstances and pieces of evidence both oral and documentary on record, it appears before the Court that the plaintiff has proved his claims. So, the Plaintiffs are held to be entitled to get her unpaid dower money; and maintenance just and reasonable according to the socio-economic conditions of the parties. Therefore, the suit deserves to be decreed in part. 

The court fee paid is sufficient.
Hence, it is ordered

         that the suit be decreed ex parte against the Defendant without any order as to costs. Accordingly, Plaintiff No. 01 is entitled to get Tk. 34,900 as dower money and Tk. 3000 as maintenance for 03 months of Iddat period, being total Tk. 37,900 by virtue of the decree. Plaintiff No. 02 is also hereby entitled to get Tk. 54,000/- [i.e. 26x1000)] as Maintenance of 54 months from the date of the institution of the very suit to date. The Defendant is ordered to pay the decreed amount within the next 30 (thirty) days from the date, failing which, the Plaintiffs may take steps in accordance with the law.

              Moreover, the minor child, plaintiff No. 02, will be getting Maintenance at the rate of Tk. 2000/- respectively per month till lawful period, and Tk. 200/- will be added with the said amount at the start of every Christian year which shall come into force from the next year. The defendant is directed to pay the monthly maintenance to Plaintiffs within the first week of every month.

             However, it is further ordered that the parties to the suit may, through the court, revise the amount of the future maintenance once within 36 months.
 
Composed and corrected by                                        
 
continue reading Ex Parte order passed in the family suit No. 57/2020 (dower and maintenance)

31 March 2022

Judgement passed in the Family Suit No. 31/2021


HEADING OF JUDGEMENT IN ORIGINAL SUIT/CASE

District: Rajshahi

In the Court of Family Judge, Mohonpur, Rajshahi

Present:  Md. Abdul Malek, Judge, Family Court

31.03.2022

Family Suit No. 31/2021

Mst. Sundori Begum Versus Mr. Md. Abdul Mojid

In the presence of.....

And having stood for consideration to this day, the Court delivered the following judgment: This family suit is for recovering maintenance against the defendant.

The Pleadings of the parties in the nutshell:

Md. Shanto Islam was born at the defendant’s paternal legitimacy. In the aftermath, After the wedlock of his parents got broken up, the impugned child has been in her mother custody; but the defendant pays no care of to the child till to date. The Defendant is alleged not to provide maintenance to his child, and even not to take their whereabouts. The minor being now in her mother’s custody demanded to the Defendant for maintenance on 29/08/21 but he refused to pay the same; and hence the suit.

On the other hand, the Defendant contested the suit by filing written statement denying the material averments made in the plaint. He contended, inter alia, that the Plaintiff lacks in locus standi, the impugned facts are fabricated and fraudulent, and the very suit is legally untenable, unjustifiable; and dismissible for the cloudy cause of actions. The Defendant stated that due to familial discords and conflicts, their marital tie sees the end. The defendant specifically asserts that the minor has been out of his custody is true; but the children is now over 7 years. He also claims that plaintiff No. 02 has no standing to sue the minor daughter and thus, he retains right to take the child into his custody. He claims that he is not capable of providing provisions for his child as per prayer. He also instituted a suit for custody of the child in questions. So, the plaintiff should not get any relief.

Issues:

Considering the pleadings of the parties, the issues are framed with modifications for discussion in the following way:

1.    Whether the suit is maintainable in the present form and manner and whether the suit is barred by limitation.

2.   Whether the plaintiff no. 01 is entitled to Maintenance as prayed for.

3.   Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get remedy as prayed for.

Discussions and the Decision

In proof of the claims, the Plaintiff side examined a witness as PW. 01 on behalf of the minor child; and produced documents; on the other side, the defendant examined himself as DW-01 in support of his claim.

Issue No. 01-03:

These issues are taken together for brevity, correlation, and convenience. The plaintiffs filed the suit before this family court having jurisdiction under the provisions of the Family Court Ordinance, 1985; and paid proper court fees, with a prayer for decree maintenance. Section 05 of the Family Court Ordinance, 1985 recognizes any aggrieved person’s right to file a lawsuit in relation to the matter of maintenance. Again, as it is admitted that the minor child is now in the custody of her maternal grandmother. So, the needful custodian of a child has full right to claim maintenance from the capable biological father. So, since there appear no contrary materials to the aforesaid premise, it is decided that the suit is maintainable in the current form and manner. Again, the whole fabric of the materials shows that the suit is not barred by limitation.

02. It is unequivocally admitted that during the continuation of valid wedlock, plaintiff No. 01 was born in the womb of her mother at the defendant’s paternal legitimacy. As aforesaid, it is also admitted fact that plaintiff No. 01 is now in the custody of her maternal grandmother. It transpires in evidence (vide PW-01, DW-01) that his minor has been out of his custody since their marriage was dissolved. The defendant also specifically admits that he has paid no money to the child in question after this suit was filed against him (vide DW-01). Accordingly, it is decisive that the impugned child has been in her mother’s since the demise of their wedlock.

03. As per the birth certificate of the child in question, she was born on 30.09.2014. Considering the evidence adduced as such, it also appears that the child was then given nothing in terms of maintenance by the defendant father from the time when the suit was brought in being. There is no evidence from the defendant side that the defendant paid some money in terms of child maintenance. In the light of the aforesaid narratives, it is decided that since this is a suit for maintenance for a minor child from her father, and the child is out of the father’s custody, and this suit is not otherwise barred in a lawful manner, the issue Nos. 01-02 are settled on the plaintiff’s behalf.

04. Now the left-out issue is that whether the plaintiffs could get the relief as much as they prayed for. The defendant only claims in his evidence that he is a farmer and works for others. It is worth mentioning that nothing more is demonstrated on the material available on the record regarding the present status and educational condition of the child. Even no sufficient account of the evidence is led as to the financial conditions or family member or dependents of the defendant.

05. With regard to the present context, it is germane to pinpoint that ‘right to maintenance’ forms a part of the personal law; and Muslim Personal Law naturally requires a father to maintain his children and take them every care. There is also a scholarly consensus on a father's obligation to bear his children's expenses due to the words of Allah the Almighty [Al-Baqarah, 233], even when the child is in its mother’s custody. Accordingly, daughters can ask for maintenance until they get married. So, the maintenance of children is, as a general rule, the responsibility of the father. Maintenance of children is, therefore, incumbent upon the father. The decided facts of the suit thus fall within the four walls of such an edifice of law.  

06. However, the applicable law also resonates that a father must be either financially capable of supporting his child or ability to earn in excess of his own expenses. A father's obligation to support his child is not waived except if he is incapable of earning a livelihood such that he is financially dependent on any of his ancestors or descendants. In such a case, the obligation to support his child is not waived. Because a child is attributed to its father and is a part of him, much weight is attached to children’s maintenance under Muslim law. Even, children have got priority over parents as far as maintenance is concerned.

8. In essence, as aforesaid, the law governing the very suit vindicates the rights of the child to be maintained by the father despite the fact that the child is in the custody of the mother or grandmother. The concept of ‘maintenance’ includes food, raiment, and lodging but this definition of ‘maintenance’ is not exhaustive. This word includes other necessary expenses for the mental and physical well-being of a minor, according to his status in society. Educational expenses were included therein. [Para 369, Mulla, Principles of Mahomedan Law, 18th Ed. (1977) reprint 1985, p. 382)]. Therefore, Plaintiff is proved to be entitled to ‘adequate’ maintenance.

09. It is even permissible to be underscored by saying that the mother cannot be compelled to provide milk to a child but the father is under a duty to provide a nurse. He is bound to maintain even if he is indigent or the children are in the custody of the mother and the like [vide 16 BLD (AD (1996)]. But such maintenance is to be assessed in cognizance of the father’s affordable conditions or the customs and practices. Likewise, it is decided that plaintiff No. 01 is proved to be entitled to past maintenance from the date of institution of the instant suit. Additionally, they will be entitled to monthly Maintenance for the lawful period. Since Plaintiff is a necessitous daughter of the defendant, it is, therefore, held that Defendant is bound to provide maintenance to his minor daughter till the lawful period. These issues are therefore decided in the plaintiff’s favor.

Additionally, as a matter of convenience, a good conscience, and reality along with the entailing circumstances, and the socio-economic conditions of the Plaintiffs and the Defendant, it is also decided that she will get tk. 1000/ per month as past maintenance, and also be entitled to monthly Maintenance for a lawful period at the rate of Tk. 1300/- for each month. In consideration of pleadings, facts, surrounding circumstances, evidence both oral and documentary on record, it appears before the Court that the suit deserves to be decreed on the contest. 

The court fee paid is sufficient.

Hence, it is ordered that the suit is decreed on contest against the defendant without any order as to costs. Accordingly, Plaintiff No. 01 is entitled to get maintenance of Taka 7,000/ [i.e., 1000x07] for a period of 07 months from the date of institution of the suit by virtue of the decree. Defendant is ordered to pay the decreed amount within the next 30 (thirty) days from the date of the order of this decree, failing which, the plaintiff may take steps in accordance with the law.

Moreover, Plaintiff No. 01 will be getting maintenance at the rate of Tk. 1300/- for each month from the date till the lawful period and Tk. 200/ shall be added up to the said amount at the beginning of January of each Christian Calendar. The defendant is directed to pay the monthly maintenance to the minor child within the first week of every month. It is also ordered that the plaintiff may through court revise the amount of the prospective maintenance once within a period of 36 months. 

         Composed and corrected by

                                  

continue reading Judgement passed in the Family Suit No. 31/2021

06 March 2022

Dismissal order passed in the miscellaneous case No. 02/21 (family)

 Seen. Perused the materials available on record. Further perused the family execution case No. 05/20 and the original family suit No. 93/2016.

Upon such perusal, it appears that the instant case is a miscellaneous case is brought in before the court against the contested judgment and decree passed in the original family suit No. 93/2016. But, the opposite party today places a petition mentioning that this miscellaneous case is not maintainable in the eye of law. Heard both sides, and looked into the relevant fact and laws. Upon close scrutiny of the matters in question, it occurs to the court that although the petition for this family miscellaneous case states that an ex parte order and decree was passed in the original family suit No. 93/2016, the real case is just the opposite. Since the original suit No. 93/2016 was decreed on contest, it is decisive that the instant case is not maintainable under section 9(6) of the 1985 Family court ordinance. With having manifest findings regarding, and the judicial notice of, the facts in issue and relevant laws, the court feels that the instant suit requires to be buried at once. Moreover, it also appears that the instant family miscellaneous case is presumed to be brought in by way of misrepresentation in the petition; it would be fair to compel the petitioner to compensate the aggrieved opposite party.  

Hence, it is ordered that the petition dated 31.05.22 be allowed; and this miscellaneous case be dismissed with costs. 

continue reading Dismissal order passed in the miscellaneous case No. 02/21 (family)

24 February 2022

Judgement passed in the Family Suit No. 60/2019 (Dower & Maintenance)

In the Court of Family Judge, Mohonpur, Rajshahi

Present: - Mr. Md. Abdul Malek, Judge, Family Court

Jan. 26, 2022

Family Suit No. 57/2017

Mst. Shanjida Khatin Versus Mr. Md. Rasel Rana Sordar

In the presence of

Mr........…….........................…...…Learned Advocate for the Plaintiffs. 

Mr.....................................………...Learned Advocate for the Defendant.

And having stood for consideration to this day, the Court delivered the following judgment: This family suit is instituted with a prayer for recovering unpaid dower money with maintenance against the Defendant.

The Plaint in the nutshell:

A marriage was contracted and Kabinnama was registered between the Plaintiff and the Defendant on 29/06/2017 in compliance with Islamic sharia; and dower was fixed at Tk. 2, 00,000/. But later on, the Defendant demanded dowry; and on refusal, he drove the Plaintiff away from his abode with trifle apparels on 25/07/2017; and they then took shelter in her father’s house. From that time, the Plaintiff is still staying at that abode; but the Defendant never looks after or provides provisions to the Plaintiff; and even is not taking their whereabouts. While living with no means, she demanded her dower money and maintenance from the defendant on 17/09/2017 through legal notice. The plaintiff also claimed that the defendant is financially solvent and has some landed property and thus, capable of satisfying them as prayed for. 

Written Statement of the Defendant:

The Defendant contested the suit by filing a written statement denying the material averments made in the plaint. He contended, inter alia, that the Plaintiff lacks in cause of actions and locus standi, the impugned facts are false and fabricated, and the very suit is legally untenable, unjustifiable; and directly dismissible. The Defendant stated that a marriage was contracted and Nikahnama was registered between the Plaintiff and the Defendant on 29/06/2017 in compliance with Islamic sharia; and dower was fixed at Tk. 2, 00,000 with instant payment of Tk. 1000 in terms of ornament. Out of familial discord and unpleasant incidents, their marital tie was dissolved through Khula talaq and Tk. 2, 00,000 was paid by the defendant to the plaintiff as dower money and iddat maintenance. The notice of talaq was also served to the concerned U.P. chairman. Hence, the plaintiff is not entitled to relief as prayed for.

Issues:

Considering the pleadings of the parties, the issues are framed in the following modified way:

1.     Whether the suit is maintainable in the present form and manner.

2.    Whether the suit is barred by limitation.

3.    Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get dower money and maintenance as prayed for.

4.    Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get remedy as prayed for. 


Discussions and Decisions

In proof of the claims, the Plaintiff side examined the witness as PW. 01; and submitted a document marked as exhibit No. 01.  On the other side, the Defendant examined two witnesses as DW. 01-02 and submitted documentary evidence marked as Ka-Chha.  After the end of the trial of the suit, a post-trial reconciliation attempt was made, and failing which, arguments are heard from both sides.

Issue No. 01 and 02:

The plaintiff filed the suit before this family court having jurisdiction under the provisions of the Family Court Ordinance, 1985; and paid proper court fees, with a prayer for a decree for dower and maintenance. Section 05 of the Family Court Ordinance, 1985 recognizes any aggrieved person’s right to file a lawsuit in relation to the matter of dower and maintenance. So, since there appear no contrary materials to the aforesaid premise, it is decided that the suit is maintainable in the current form and manner. Again, the whole fabric of the materials shows that the suit is not barred by limitation. Hence, these issues are settled in the plaintiff’s favor.

Issue No. 03:

Presumably, where there is a marriage, there is a dower. Upon perusal of the materials available on record, it appears that the marriage in question was contracted and registered in a Nikahnama (vide exhibit-01). Besides, the evidence adduced by the PW-01 and DW-01, it appears that both parties admitted the facts of solemnization of a valid marriage with fixing dower money at Tk. 2,00,000/. However, the certified copy of Nikahnama speaks out that the nature of the dower is found to be uncertain. Therefore, as per section 10 of the 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, the entire amount of dower shall be payable on demand, no matter marital tie subsists or not. Although the defendant in his pleading claims that the dower money was fixed at Tk. 2, 00,000 with instant payment of Tk. 1000 in terms of ornament, he neither substantiates in his evidence as DW-01, nor produced any supporting documents in this regard.  So, the averment of the certified copy of Nikahnama (vide exhibit-01) should get preponderance in this respect. Accordingly, the whole dower money of Tk. 2, 00,000 is hereby decided as prompt dower. Hence, it is decided that a valid marriage was contracted with fixing prompt dower money of Tk. 2,00,000 between the plaintiff and defendant.

04. Since marriage is admitted, the plaintiff is entitled to maintenance. A question arises whether the plaintiff is entitled to continued maintenance or only iddat maintenance. On perusal of the materials on record, it appears that the defendant claims the dissolution of their marriage through Khula talaq, but the plaintiff does not admit it neither in pleading nor in her evidence. Here thus becomes an issue whether their marital tie now subsists or not.

05. On careful perusal of materials on record, and exhibited documents, it apparently appears that the defendant placed before the court a true copy of the notice of Talak, registry postal receipts and acknowledgments, affidavit upon the pronouncement of Khula Talak, and the certified copy of Talak-registration[ext.: Ka-Chha]. Although the plaintiff as PW-01 denied the fact of receiving any notice of talaq from the defendant, she could not present any evidentiary materials contrary to the plaintiff’s documentary evidence. On careful perusal of documents enumerated just hereinbefore, it is the view of the court that there exists proof of the fact relating to the fact that notices of Talak were issued both to the plaintiff and the concerned U.P. chairman through registry postal letters. Specifically, it is substantiated with pre-eminent evidential materials that the required notice of Talak was ‘delivered’ to the concerned chairman, and ninety days expired from the day on which notice under sub-section (1) is delivered to the Chairman without any reconciliation in whatsoever.

06. Now consider the statutory provision in this respect. Section 7 of the 1961Muslim Family Laws Ordinance stipulates that “Any man who wishes to divorce his wife shall, as soon as may be after the pronouncement of talaq in any form whatsoever, give the Chairman notice in writing of his having done so, and shall supply a copy thereof to the wife. It also envisages that “Save, as provided in sub-section (5), a talaq unless revoked earlier, expressly or otherwise, shall not be effective until the expiration of ninety days from the day on which notice under sub-section (1) is delivered to the Chairman.

07. The plain reading of the above statutory provision gives us a lucid understanding that any pronouncement of talaq shall not be effective until the expiration of ninety days from the day on which notice under sub-section (1) is delivered to the Chairman. The words “in any form whatsoever” appearing in section 7(1) of the Ordinance 1961 is very much significant; as it spells out that “in any form" means and includes khula talaq too; no matter whether talaq is registered or not), or no matter whether any modes of Talaq stated in Mahomedan Law. Because, section 7 requires only a notice of a talaq to be given to the Chairman in order to give effect to divorce. In fact, Khula or Mubara'at is another form of talaq or dissolution of marriage by agreement Khula or Mubarat is stated in section 319 of Mulla's Principles of Mahomedan Law. In legal parlance, it is in this regard well-settled that a divorce is legally effective even in the absence of proof of the constitution of the Arbitration Council. Moreover, a divorce disclosed in an ‘affidavit’ gains good ground in proof of dissolution of marriages.

08. Accordingly, it apparently appears that as per the relevant provisions of section 7 of the 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, the defendant is found to be successful in proving a legally-effected-talak with credible shreds of evidence. So, the defendant-led-reliable-evidences relating to the proof of Talak are evidentiary value-laden, it is crystal to the court that their wedlock subsists no more. In the light of the discussion made hereinbefore, the court is of view that Talak is proved to be effective, the plaintiff shall get her iddat maintenance. Therefore, it is decisive to the court that the plaintiff is held to be entitled to get her “unpaid” dower and “iddat” maintenance.

09. The next question as it ensues, how much provisions of iddat maintenance, or whether at a rate as it is prayed for? The plaintiff claimed that the defendant's familial as well as financial conditions are well off. He has some landed property, and is thus capable of satisfying them as prayed for. In evidence, they concurred with the same propositions (vide PW-01). On the other hand, the defendant claims that he is van driver, and has no landed property. He also stated in cross-examination that he earns tk. 100/500 per day. In fact, it appears that the record contains no sufficient materials to decide upon the socio-economic conditions of the parties to the suit.

10. On further perusal of the materials on record, there also arises another incidental question that poses as one of the most crucial questions to decide in this suit. That is to say, the question is whether dower money is still unpaid or not. As aforesaid, although the defendant in his pleading claims that the dower money was fixed at Tk. 2, 00,000 with instant payment of Tk. 1000 in terms of ornament, he neither substantiates in his evidence as DW-01, nor produced any supporting documents in this regard.  So, as per the averment of the certified copy of Nikahnama (vide exhibit-01), the whole amount of dower money (Tk. 2, 00,000) is unpaid, if subsequently proved to be not paid at all.

11. In evidence, it is conspicuous that the plaintiff is examined as PW-01 and the defendant made cross-examination to her as well but put no question to her as to how she took or he paid the dower money, or how the transaction of payment of dower money was made in between; except the fact of putting her signature on the agreement of Khula talaq. Here, the plaintiff denied the claims of the defendant as to his payment of dower money to her. The defendant as DW-01 deposed that he has already paid the dower money to the plaintiff at the (Rajshahi) court premise through the affidavit in the presence of one Mozammel (DW-02) and one Nazrul (not examined before the court).  The agreement of Khula talaq is disclosed in the affidavit, which contains an averment that dower money is paid to the plaintiff. It appears that although the time of payment of dower money is significant, the DWs 01-02 could not tell the court when that agreement was executed at the court premise. 

12. Moreover, neither the notary public officer nor the identifying advocate was examined by the defendant side before the court. Even no expert evidence as to the parties’ signature is available on record on the defendant’s side. Besides, the defendant’s assertion appears to be unconvincing because how he managed those amounts of money (2 lakhs) is not proved by examining the defendant’s cousin one Dulal, from whom he borrowed money, as he claims (vide DW 01, cross-examination). He further failed to produce the purchase or sale receipt of his auto (vehicle) as a part of a series of transaction relevant to the fact in issue. Surprisingly, no one was present on behalf of the plaintiff when the alleged payment of dower money to the plaintiff was made.

13. The defendant’s case apparently also becomes unconvincing if the fact of their returning from the court premise to their home is carefully considered. The DW-01 asserted that his mother went with the plaintiff while she were returning to her home from the court premises.  But the DW-02 claims that the defendant, his mother, and he together returned to their home. Moreover, the defendant’s affidavit is a personal oath or affirmation which is based on his own knowledge. The rules of evidence do not apply to affidavits. The bottom line is that what it transpires, such incongruent and contradictory evidence carries the defendant nowhere. Therefore, considering the discussion made hereinbefore, it appears to the court that the defendant has not become successful in proving his claim that he has already paid the dower money to the plaintiff. Hence, it is decided that the whole amount of dower money (Tk. 2, 00,000) is still unpaid, and thus, the plaintiff is found to be entitled to recover it from the defendant. This issue is settled in the plaintiff’s favor.

Issue No. 04:

In the light of the socio-economic conditions of the Plaintiff and defendant to the extent of what the available evidence goes, as well as the entailing circumstances and conditions reflected in the instant case, it appears that the plaintiff has proved her case with satisfactory and convincing materials of evidence. Since all issues are settled in the plaintiff’s favor, the suit will be decreed, but in part. In consideration of pleadings, facts, surrounding circumstances, evidence both oral and documentary on record, the court is of view that the suit deserves to be decreed on the contest in part 

Court fee paid is sufficient.

Hence, it is ordered

that the suit be decreed in part on contest against the defendant without any order as to costs. The plaintiff is hereby entitled to get Tk. 2,00,000/- as unpaid dower money; and Tk. 3,000 (3x1000) as iddat Maintenance; in toto, Tk. 2,03,000 [i.e. (2,00,000+3,000]  by virtue of the decree. The defendant is ordered to pay the decreed amount within the next 30 (thirty) days from the date, failing which, the Plaintiff may take steps in accordance with the law.


continue reading Judgement passed in the Family Suit No. 60/2019 (Dower & Maintenance)

23 February 2022

Ex parte order passed in the family suit No. 02/2021

A family suit for recovery of dower money and spousal maintenance

Perused the Plaint, Plaintiff’s deposition given as PW-01, and documentary evidence available on the record. This is a family suit instituted on 18/01/21 and prayed for recovering dower money, and maintenance against Defendant. With assigning some reasons, Plaintiff prayed for the recovery of unpaid dower money and Maintenance for herself. It appears that the marriage was contracted and registered between Plaintiff and Defendant on 12/06/2020 (vide ext: 01). Exhibit No. 01, the certified copy of the registered Nikahnama, demonstrates that the dower was fixed at Tk. 1,40,000/- only with the instant payment of 500/ only. But the nature of the dower is found to be uncertain. Therefore, as per section 10 of the 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, the entire amount of dower shall be payable on demand. Accordingly, the whole unpaid dower Tk. 1,39,500/- is decided as a prompt dower. So, it is decided that plaintiff No. 01 is entitled to her prompt dower of Tk. 1,39,500/- which remains unpaid to date.

On perusal of the plaintiff’s deposition given as PW-01, it appears to the Court that the marital tie between the Plaintiff and Defendant still subsists. It is also asserted that the defendant has also some of the landed properties, and is capable of working. A local business also belongs to him. He has contracted a second marriage with another woman and lives with his parents in their own house.

In consideration of the pleading, facts, surrounding circumstances, and evidence both oral and documentary on record, it appears before the Court that the plaintiff has proved his claims in part. So, Plaintiff is held to be entitled to get her unpaid prompt dower money of Tk. 1,39,500/- (as prompt dower); and Maintenance just and reasonable according to the socio-economic conditions of the parties. Therefore, the suit deserves to be decreed.

Court fee paid is sufficient.

Hence, it is ordered

that the suit be decreed ex parte against the Defendant without any order as to costs. Accordingly, Plaintiff is hereby entitled to get Tk. 1,39,500/- as unpaid prompt dower; and Tk. 13,000/- i.e. (13x1000), as past maintenance for the last 13 months from the date of the suit’s institution, by virtue of the decree. The defendant is ordered to pay the decreed amount within the next 30 (thirty) days from the date, failing which, Plaintiff may take steps in accordance with the law.

Moreover, it is ordered that Plaintiff will be getting her Maintenance at the rate of Tk. 2000/- respectively per month from the date till the lawful period; and additionally, 200/- taka will be added with the said amount in terms of spouse maintenance at the start of every Christian year which shall come into force from the next year. The defendant is directed to pay the monthly maintenance to the plaintiff within the first week of every month. However, it is further ordered that the plaintiff may through court revise the amount of the prospective maintenance once within a period of three years, if applicable.

continue reading Ex parte order passed in the family suit No. 02/2021